Report on compliance with the Bank of Russia’s corporate governance code
| Corporate governance principles | Criteria for assessing compliance with corporate governance principle | Compliance | Explanations of deviations from the criteria for assessing compliance with corporate governance principle | |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | |
1.1 | The company shall ensure equal and fair treatment of all shareholders in exercising their corporate governance right | ||||
1.1.1 | The company ensures the most favourable conditions for its shareholders to participate in the general meeting, develop informed positions on agenda items of the general meeting, coordinate their actions, and voice their opinions on items considered |
| Full compliance | ||
1.1.2 | The procedure for giving notice of, and providing relevant materials for, the general meeting enables shareholders to properly prepare for attending the general meeting |
| Partial compliance | 1 – partial compliance. In the reporting period, the notice of the General Meeting of Shareholders was posted (published) on the Company’s website less than 30 days before the date of the General Meeting of Shareholders, however the rights of the shareholders were not violated. 2 – full compliance. 3 – full compliance | |
1.1.3 | In preparation for the general meeting and during the general meeting, shareholders were enabled to receive information about, and all materials related to, the meeting, put questions to executive bodies and members of the board of directors, as well as communicate with each other, in an unobstructed and timely manner |
| Full compliance | ||
1.1.4 | Shareholders did not encounter unjustified difficulties in exercising their right to request that a general meeting be convened, to nominate candidates to governing bodies, and to make proposals for the agenda of the general meeting |
| Full compliance | ||
1.1.5 | Each shareholder was enabled to freely exercise his/her voting right in the simplest and most convenient way |
| Full compliance | ||
1.1.6 | The general meeting procedure established by the company equally enables all persons attending the meeting to voice their opinions and ask questions |
| Partial compliance | 1 – full compliance. 2 – partial compliance: the major shareholder entitled to nominate candidates to the Company’s governing bodies conducts all necessary interviews with candidates when preparing respective proposals. 3 – partial compliance. 4 – full compliance | |
1.2 | Shareholders have equal and fair rights to share profits of the company by receiving dividends | ||||
1.2.1 | The company has developed and introduced a transparent and clear mechanism for determining the dividend amount and paying dividends |
| Partial compliance | 1 – full compliance. 2 – partial compliance: JSC FPC’s Dividend Policy uses the Company’s reporting figures to determine the dividend amount, and the respective provisions of the Dividend Policy take into account the RAS financial statements. 3 – full compliance | |
1.2.2 | The company does not resolve to pay out dividends if such resolution, while formally remaining in line with statutory restrictions, is not economically feasible and may lead to a false representation of the company’s performance |
| Full compliance | ||
1.2.3 | The company does not allow the dividend rights of its existing shareholders to be impaired |
| Full compliance | ||
1.2.4 | The company strives to exclude any ways for its shareholders to receive profit (income) from the company other than dividends and liquidation value |
| Full compliance | ||
1.3 | Corporate governance system and practices ensure equal treatment for all shareholders owning the same type (class) of shares, including minority and non-resident shareholders, and their equal treatment by the company | ||||
1.3.1 | The company has created conditions for fair treatment of each shareholder by the governing bodies and the company’s controlling entities, including conditions ruling out abuse of minority shareholders by major shareholders |
| Full compliance | ||
1.3.2 | The Company does not take any actions that lead or may lead to an artificial redistribution of corporate control |
| Full compliance | ||
1.4 | Shareholders are provided with reliable and effective methods for recording their rights in shares, as well as are enabled to freely dispose of their shares without any hindrance | ||||
1.4.1 | Shareholders are provided with reliable and effective methods for recording their rights in shares, as well as are enabled to freely dispose of their shares without any hindrance |
| Full compliance | ||
2.1 | The board of directors carries out the strategic management of the company, establish the basic principles of, and approaches to, setting up a risk management and internal control system in the company, control the activities of the company’s executive bodies, and perform other key functions | ||||
2.1.1 | The board of directors is responsible for passing resolutions related to appointment and removal of the members of executive bodies, including due to their inadequate performance. The board of directors also ensures that the company’s executive bodies act in accordance with the approved growth strategy and along the company’s core lines of business |
| Full compliance | ||
2.1.2 | The board of directors defines the main long-term targets of the company’s operations, assesses and approves its key performance indicators and key business goals, as well as the strategy and business plans for the company’s core lines of business |
| Full compliance | ||
2.1.3 | The board of directors determines the principles of, and approaches to, organising a risk management and internal control system in the company |
| Full compliance | ||
2.1.4 | The board of directors defines the company’s policy on remuneration due to, and/or reimbursement (compensation) of costs to the members of the board of directors, executive bodies, and other key managers of the company |
| Full compliance | ||
2.1.5 | The board of directors plays a key role in preventing, identifying and settling internal conflicts between the company’s bodies, shareholders and employees |
| Full compliance | ||
2.1.6 | The board of directors plays a key role in ensuring the company’s transparency, the timeliness and completeness of its information disclosures, and unhindered access to the company’s documents for shareholders |
| Full compliance | ||
2.1.7 | The board of directors controls the company’s corporate governance practices and plays a key role in its significant corporate events |
| Full compliance | ||
2.2 | The board of directors is accountable to the company’s shareholders | ||||
2.2.1 | Performance of the board of directors is disclosed and made available to the shareholders |
| Partial compliance | 1 – no compliance. Information on the attendance of the Board of Directors and committees by each of the members of the Company’s Board of Directors was not disclosed based on the right granted to the Company by Russian Government Decree No. 351 dated 22 March 2022. Information will be included in the Company’s annual reports, provided that there is no risk of restrictive measures being imposed on the Company. 2 – full compliance | |
2.2.2 | The chairman of the board of directors is available to communicate with the company’s shareholders |
| Full compliance | ||
2.3 | The board of directors manages the company in an efficient and competent manner and makes fair and independent judgements and decisions in line with the best interests of the company and its shareholders | ||||
2.3.1 | Only persons with impeccable business and personal reputation, possessing the knowledge and expertise required to make decisions falling within the authority of the board of directors and to essential performing its functions efficiently are elected to the board of directors |
| Full compliance | ||
2.3.2 | The company’s directors are elected via a transparent procedure, enabling shareholders to obtain information on nominees sufficient to judge on their personal and professional qualities |
| Full compliance | ||
2.3.3 | The board of directors is balanced, including in terms of qualifications of its members, their experience, knowledge and business qualities, and has the trust of shareholders |
| Full compliance | ||
2.3.4 | The company has a sufficient number of directors to organise the board of directors’ activities in the most efficient way, including the ability to set up committees of the board of directors and enable the company’s substantial minority shareholders to elect a nominee to the board of directors for whom they vote |
| Full compliance | ||
2.4 | The board of directors includes a sufficient number of independent directors | ||||
2.4.1 | An independent director is a person of sufficient professionalism, experience and self-reliance to form his/her own opinion, able to make impartial judgements in good faith independent of the company’s executive bodies, particular groups of shareholders or other stakeholders. It should be noted that under normal circumstance a nominee (elected director) cannot be considered independent if he/she is related to the company, its substantial shareholder or counterparty, the company’s competitor, or the government |
| Full compliance | ||
2.4.2 | The compliance of nominees to the board of directors with the criteria for independence is assessed, and a regular review of compliance of independent directors with such criteria is performed. Substance prevails over form in such assessments |
| Full compliance | ||
2.4.3 | Independent directors make up at least one third of the elected board of directors |
| Full compliance | ||
2.4.4 | Independent directors play a key role in preventing internal conflicts in the company and in the performance by the latter of material corporate actions |
| Partial compliance | In the reporting period, the Board of Directors reviewed the matters of an additional issue of JSC FPC shares. These material corporate actions were not interested-party transactions | |
2.5 | The chairman of the board of directors facilitates the best performance of assigned duties by the board of directors | ||||
2.5.1 | The board of directors is chaired by an independent director, or a senior independent director is chosen from among the elected independent directors to coordinate the activities of independent directors and enable the interaction with the chairman of the board of directors |
| Partial compliance | 1 – no compliance. The Chairman of JSC FPC’s Board of Directors is not an independent director. The candidate to become Chairman of FPC’s Board of Directors is approved by the Board of Directors of the Parent Company. Independent directors do not require additional coordination; a senior independent director is not appointed. 2 – full compliance | |
2.5.2 | The chairman of the board of directors maintains a constructive environment at meetings, enables free discussions of agenda items, and supervises the execution of resolutions passed by the board of directors |
| Full compliance | ||
2.5.3 | The chairman of the board of directors takes all steps necessary for the timely provision to directors of information required to pass resolutions on agenda items |
| Full compliance | ||
2.6 | Directors act reasonably and in good faith in the best interests of the company and its shareholders, relying on sufficient information, exercising due care and prudence | ||||
2.6.1 | Directors make decisions based on all information available, without conflict of interest, subject to equal treatment of the company’s shareholders, and assuming normal business risks |
| Full compliance | ||
2.6.2 | The rights and obligations of directors are clearly defined and set out in the company’s internal documents |
| Full compliance | ||
2.6.3 | Directors have sufficient time to perform their duties |
| Full compliance | ||
2.6.4 | All directors have equal access to the company’s documents and information. Newly elected directors are furnished with sufficient information about the company and performance of the board of directors as soon as possible |
| Full compliance | ||
2.7 | Meetings of the board of directors, preparation for such meetings and participation of directors ensure efficient performance by the board of directors | ||||
2.7.1 | Meetings of the board of directors are held as needed, taking into account the scale of operations and goals of the company at a particular time |
| Full compliance | ||
2.7.2 | The company’s internal regulations formalise a procedure for arranging and holding meetings of the board of directors, enabling members of the board of directors to prepare for such meetings properly |
| Full compliance | ||
2.7.3 | The format of the meeting of the board of directors is determined taking into account the importance of items on the agenda. The most important matters shall be dealt with at meetings of the board of directors held in person |
| Partial compliance | The Regulations on the Board of Directors of JSC FPC contain a recommendation to the Board of Directors to deal with the most important matters at meetings held in person. The list of such matters is specified in paragraph 4.4 of the Regulations on the Board of Directors of JSC FPC | |
2.7.4 | Resolutions on the most important matters related to the company’s operations are passed at a meeting of the board of directors by a qualified majority or by a majority of all elected directors |
| Partial compliance | In accordance with paragraph 18.10 of the Articles of Association, resolutions of the Company’s Board of Directors on including the persons nominated by shareholders or the Company’s Board of Directors in the list of members of the collegial executive body or the Company’s Auditing Commission, or on approving the auditor and electing the person acting as the sole executive body of each company created through reorganisation in the form of merger, division or spin-off, as well as in cases stipulated by the Federal Law On Joint Stock Companies, are passed by a majority of at least three quarters of the total number of Directors. In accordance with paragraph 18.11 of the Articles of Association, resolutions of the Company’s Board of Directors on matters listed in subparagraphs 1, 12, 21, 25, 27, 38, 43–45 and 47 of paragraph 15.1, Article 15 of the present Articles of Association, as well as on approving the Company’s Dividend Policy are passed by a majority of the members of Company’s Board of Directors | |
2.8 | The board of directors sets up committees to preview the most important matters related to the company’s operations | ||||
2.8.1 | To preview matters related to controlling the Company’s financial and business activities, it is recommended to set up an audit committee comprised of independent directors |
| Partial compliance | 1 – partial compliance. Members of the Board of Directors who are representatives of the shareholder are involved in the work of the Audit Committee. The Audit Committee has an independent director. 2 – full compliance. 3 – full compliance. 4 – full compliance | |
2.8.2 | To preview matters related to adopting an efficient and transparent remuneration scheme, a remuneration committee was set up, comprised of independent directors and headed by an independent director who is not the chairman of the board of directors |
| Partial compliance | 1 – partial compliance. The Company established the Human Resources, Remuneration and Corporate Governance Committee consisting of two independent directors, representatives of the shareholder. 2 – full compliance. 3 – partial compliance. The Regulation on the Human Resources, Remuneration and Corporate Governance Committee does not contain the tasks contained in recommendation 180(4) of the Code. | |
2.8.3 | To preview matters related to talent management (succession planning), professional composition and efficiency of the board of directors, a nomination (appointments, human resources) committee was set up, predominantly comprised of independent directors |
| Partial compliance | 1 – partial compliance. JSC FPC has set up the Human Resources, Remuneration, and Corporate Governance Committee of the Board of Directors of JSC FPC. The roles of this Committee are set out in the Regulations on the Committee of FPC’s Board of Directors and comply with recommendations of the Corporate Governance Code concerning the remuneration committee and the nomination committee. Two independent directors were elected to the Committee, one of whom chairs it. 2 – full compliance. 3 – no compliance. Due to the specific nature of the Company’s corporate governance model, the major shareholder, who has the right to nominate candidates to the Company’s governing bodies, forms proposals on the membership of the Board of Directors that best meets the Company’s goals and objectives | |
2.8.4 | Taking into account the company’s scope of business and level of risks, the company’s board of directors made sure that the composition of its committees is fully in line with the company’s business goals. Additional committees were either set up or not deemed necessary (strategy committee, corporate governance committee, ethics committee, risk management committee, budget committee, health, safety and environment committee, etc.) |
| Full compliance | ||
2.8.5 | Committees are composed so as to enable comprehensive discussions of matters under preview, taking into account the diversity of opinions |
| Partial compliance | 1 – partial compliance. During the reporting period, the Human Resources, Remuneration and Corporate Governance Committee was chaired by an independent director. The Audit and Risk Committee of the Board of Directors was chaired by an independent director until 30 June 2022. 2 – full compliance | |
2.8.6 | Committee chairmen inform the board of directors and its chairman on the work of their committees on a regular basis |
| Full compliance | ||
2.9 | The board of directors ensures performance assessment of the board of directors, its committees and members of the board of directors | ||||
2.9.1 | The board of directors ensures the assessment of performance of the board of directors, its committees and members of the board of directors, whether their work meets the company’s development needs, as well intensifying the work of the board of directors and identifying opportunities for the improvement of its performance |
| Partial compliance | 1 – full compliance. 2 – full compliance. 3 – no compliance. The results of the Board of Directors’ self-assessment were reviewed at a meeting in absentia on 30 August 2022. | |
2.9.2 | The performance of the board of directors, committees and members of the board of directors is assessed on a regular basis at least once a year. An external organisation (consultant) is engaged at least once every three years to carry out an independent assessment of the board of directors’ performance |
| No compliance | The performance of the Board of Directors was not assessed in the reporting period | |
3.1 | The company’s corporate secretary ensures efficient ongoing interaction with shareholders, coordinate the company’s efforts to protect shareholder rights and interests, and supports the activities of the board of directors | ||||
3.1.1 | The corporate secretary has the knowledge, experience and qualifications sufficient to perform his/her duties, as well as an impeccable reputation and the trust of shareholders |
| No compliance | Biographic information on the Corporate Secretary was not disclosed based on the right granted to the Company by the Russian Government regulations No. 351 dated 22 March 2022 | |
3.1.2 | The corporate secretary is sufficiently independent of the company’s executive bodies and has the powers and resources required to perform his/her tasks |
| Full compliance | ||
4.1 | Remuneration payable by the company is sufficient to attract, motivate and retain people with competencies and qualifications required by the company. Remuneration payable to directors, executive bodies and other key managers of the company is in compliance with the approved remuneration policy of the company | ||||
4.1.1 | The amount of remuneration paid by the company to the members of the board of directors, executive bodies and other key managers creates sufficient incentives for them to work efficiently while enabling the company to engage and retain competent and qualified specialists. At the same time, the company avoids unnecessarily high remuneration, as well as unjustifiably large gaps between remunerations of the above persons and the company’s employees |
| Full compliance | ||
4.1.2 | The company’s remuneration policy is devised by the remuneration committee and approved by the board of directors. The board of directors, assisted by the remuneration committee, ensures control over the introduction and implementation of the company’s remuneration policy, revising and amending it as required |
| Full compliance | ||
4.1.3 | The company’s remuneration policy includes transparent mechanisms for determining the amount of remuneration due to directors, executive bodies and other key managers of the company, and regulate all types of expenses, benefits and privileges provided to such persons |
| Full compliance | ||
4.1.4 | The company defines a policy on reimbursement (compensation) of costs, detailing a list of reimbursable expenses and specifying service levels that members of the board of directors, executive bodies and other key managers of the company can claim. Such policy can make part of the company’s remuneration policy |
| Partial compliance | The procedure for reimbursement of expenses of the Company’s executives on renting residential premises from third-party owners, other than members of the Board of Directors and executive bodies, is stipulated by the Order of JSC FPC No. 859r dated 11 September 2017 On Formation and Use of the Specialised Housing Fund of JSC FPC. In accordance with paragraph 4.4.29 of the Collective Bargaining Agreement of JSC FPC for 2020–2022, the employees of JSC FPC, including the key executives of the Company, are compensated for the costs of maintaining their children in private pre-school educational institutions of the Parent Company. Compensation is paid in accordance with the procedure and in the amounts set out in Section V of the Regulation on Social Support Measures for Employees of the Management Staff of JSC FPC and Centres (Business Units) of JSC FPC, their Family Members and Non-working Pensioners No. 63r dated 25 January 2018. In accordance with Article 169 of the Russian Labour Code, the employees of JSC FPC, including the key executives of the Company, are reimbursed, upon prior agreement with the employer, for the costs of moving an employee, his/her family members and property (unless the employer provides such employee with appropriate means of transport) and the costs of settling in at the new place of residence when moving to another place of residence to continue his/her work. Specific amounts of reimbursement of the costs are determined by the parties to the employment contract | |
4.2 | Remuneration system for directors ensures alignment of financial interests of directors with long term financial interests of shareholders | ||||
4.2.1 | The company pays fixed annual remuneration to directors. The company does not pay remuneration for attending particular meetings of the board of directors or its committees. The company does not apply any form of short-term motivation or additional financial incentive for directors |
| Full compliance | ||
4.2.2 | Long-term ownership of the company’s shares helps align the financial interests of directors with long-term interests of shareholders to the utmost. At the same time, the company does not link the right to dispose of shares to performance targets, and directors do not participate in stock option plans |
| No compliance | Not applicable. Regulations on Payment of Remuneration and Compensations to Members of the Board of Directors do not provide for granting shares in the Company to the members of the Board of Directors | |
4.2.3 | The company does not provide for any extra payments or compensations in the event of early termination of directors’ mandates resulting from the change of control or any other reasons |
| Full compliance | ||
4.3 | The company considers its performance and the personal contribution of each executive to the achievement of such performance, when determining the amount of a fee payable to members of executive bodies and other key managers of the company | ||||
4.3.1 | Remuneration due to members of executive bodies and other key managers of the company is determined in a manner providing for reasonable and justified ratio of the fixed and variable parts of remuneration, depending on the company’s results and the employee’s personal contribution |
| Full compliance | ||
4.3.2 | The company has in place a long-term incentive programme for members of executive bodies and other key managers of the company with the use of the company’s shares (options and other derivative instruments where the company’s shares are the underlying asset) |
| No compliance | The Company does not have a long-term incentive stock option plan for top managers. The Company uses other management incentives based on the achievement of the KPIs set by the Company’s Board of Directors | |
4.3.3 | The compensation (golden parachute) payable by the company in case of early termination of powers of members of executive bodies or key managers at the company’s initiative, provided that there have been no actions in bad faith on their part, does not exceed the double amount of the fixed part of their annual remuneration |
| Full compliance | ||
5.1 | The company has in place an effective risk management and internal control system, providing reasonable assurance in the achievement of the company’s goals | ||||
5.1.1 | The company’s board of directors determined the principles of, and approaches to, organising a risk management and internal control system in the company |
| Full compliance | ||
5.1.2 | The company’s executive bodies ensure establishment and continuous operation of an efficient risk management and internal control system in the company |
| Full compliance | ||
5.1.3 | The company’s risk management and internal control system ensures an objective, fair and clear representation of the current state of the company and its future prospects, the integrity and transparency of the company’s reporting, as well as reasonable and acceptable risk exposure |
| Full compliance | ||
5.1.4 | The company’s board of directors takes necessary measures to make sure that the company’s risk management and internal control system is consistent with the principles of, and approaches to its setting up determined by the board of directors, and that the system is functioning efficiently |
| Full compliance | ||
5.2 | The company performs internal audits for regular independent assessment of the reliability and effectiveness of the risk management and internal control system, as well as corporate governance practices | ||||
5.2.1 | The company has set up a separate business unit or engaged an independent external organisation to carry out internal audits. The functional and administrative reporting lines of the internal audit unit are delineated. The internal audit unit functionally reports to the board of directors. |
| Full compliance | ||
5.2.2 | The internal audit unit assesses the reliability and effectiveness of the risk management and internal control systems as well as the corporate governance, and applies generally accepted internal auditing standards |
| Full compliance | ||
6.1 | The company and its business are transparent for shareholders, investors and other stakeholders | ||||
6.1.1 | The company has developed and adopted an information policy ensuring an efficient exchange of information between the company, its shareholders, investors and other stakeholders |
| Full compliance | ||
6.1.2 | The company discloses information on its corporate governance system and practices, including detailed information on compliance with the principles and recommendations of this Code |
| Partial compliance | 1 – full compliance. 2 – no compliance. The information was not disclosed based on the Russian Federation Government Resolution No. 351 dated 22 March 2022. 3 – no compliance. A memorandum is not available. | |
6.2 | The company makes timely disclosures of complete, updated and reliable information to allow shareholders and investors to make informed decisions | ||||
6.2.1 | The company discloses information based on the principles of regularity, consistency and promptness, as well as availability, reliability, completeness and comparability of disclosed data |
| Partial compliance | 1 – full compliance. 2 – not applicable. The Company’s securities are not traded on foreign organised markets. 3 – not applicable. JSC FPC has no foreign shareholders | |
6.2.2 | The company avoids a formalistic approach to information disclosure and discloses critical information about its operations even if such disclosure is not required by law |
| Partial compliance | 1 – full compliance. 2 – partial compliance. The following paragraphs of recommendation 290 of the Code are not applicable to the activities of JSC FPC:
3 – full compliance. 4 – partial compliance. The company discloses non-financial reports — a sustainability report, an environmental report, a corporate social responsibility report or another report containing non-financial information, including factors related to the environment (inter alia, environmental and climate change related factors), society (social factors) and corporate governance, within the annual report only | |
6.2.3 | The annual report, as one of the most important tools of information exchange with shareholders and other stakeholders, contains information enabling assessment of the company’s performance in the reporting year |
| Partial compliance | 1 – no compliance. The annual report of the company contains information on the results of the assessment by the audit committee of the effectiveness of the external and internal audit process. 2 – full compliance | |
6.3 | The company provides information and documents as per the requests of shareholders in compliance with principles of fairness and ease of access | ||||
6.3.1 | Shareholders can exercise their right of access to company documents and information without unnecessary difficulties |
| Full compliance | ||
6.3.2 | When providing information to shareholders, the company ensures reasonable balance between the interests of particular shareholders and its own interests, consisting in preserving the confidentiality of important commercial information which may materially affect its competitiveness |
| Full compliance | ||
7.1 | Actions that significantly impact or may significantly impact the share capital structure or financial condition of the company and, respectively, shareholders position (material corporate actions) are fairly executed providing observance of rights and interests of shareholders and other stakeholders | ||||
7.1.1 | Material corporate actions include restructuring of the company, acquisition of 30% or more of the company’s voting shares (takeover), execution by the company of significant transactions, increase or reduction of the company’s authorised capital, listing or de-listing of the company’s shares, as well as other actions which may lead to material changes in the rights of shareholders or violation of their interests. The company’s articles of association define a list of transactions or other actions classified as material corporate actions pertaining to the competence of the company’s board of directors |
| Full compliance | ||
7.1.2 | The board of directors plays a key role in making decisions or working out recommendations regarding material corporate actions, relying on the opinions of the company’s independent directors |
| Full compliance | ||
7.1.3 | When taking material corporate actions affecting the rights and legitimate interests of shareholders, equal terms and conditions are ensured for all shareholders of the company, and, in case of insufficient statutory mechanisms for protecting shareholder rights, additional measures are taken to protect the rights and legitimate interests of the company’s shareholders. In doing so, the company is guided by the corporate governance principles set forth in the Code, as well as by formal statutory requirements. |
| Full compliance | ||
7.2 | The company performs material corporate actions in such a way as to ensure that shareholders timely receive complete information about such actions, allowing them to influence such actions and guaranteeing adequate protection of their rights when performing such actions | ||||
7.2.1 | Information about material corporate actions is disclosed with explanations of the grounds, circumstances and consequences |
| Full compliance
| ||
7.2.2 | The rules and procedures related to material corporate actions are set forth in the company’s internal documents |
| Partial compliance | 1 – no compliance. The company’s internal documents provide for the procedure for engaging an independent appraiser to determine the value of the property disposed of or acquired pursuant to a major transaction or an interested party transaction. 2 – full compliance. 3 – no compliance. FPC’s Articles of Association stipulate that the provisions of Chapter XI of the Federal Law On Joint Stock Companies do not apply to transactions in which the Company’s controlling entity is an interested party |